Showing posts with label Bills. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bills. Show all posts

Friday, September 20, 2013

Whistleblowers



who is a whistleblower ?

A whistleblower (whistle-blower or whistle blower) is a person who exposes misconduct, alleged dishonest or illegal activity occurring in an organization. The alleged misconduct may be classified in many ways; for example, a violation of a law, rule, regulation and/or a direct threat to public interest, such as fraud, health and safety violations, and corruption. Whistleblowers may make their allegations internally (for example, to other people within the accused organization) or externally (to regulators, law enforcement agencies, to the media or to groups concerned with the issues).

Types of Whistleblowers :
  • Internal whistleblowers – Report the misconduct or illegal behavior of a fellow employee or superior within a company
  • External whistleblowers – Not directly involved in a company, but report their actions to entities such as the media, law enforcement, and watchdog agencies
  • Current Whistleblower - One who blows the whistle while he/she is still a member of the organization
  • Alumni Whistleblower - One who blows the whisle after leaving the organization
  • Open Whistleblower - One who reveals his or her identiity and/or makes no attempt to hide identity
  • Anonymous Whistleblower - One who keeps his/her identity a secret
Many whistleblowers, such as Erin Brockovitch, Sanjiv Chaturvedi (IFS) ,S.K. Lamba (exposed Adarsh scam), Satyendra Dubey(NHAI),Jeffrey Wigand,etc. are considered public heroes. 

Perception about the whisteblowers 

Whistleblowers are sometimes seen as selfless martyrs for public interest and organizational accountability; others view them as "traitors" or "defectors," solely pursuing personal glory and fame, or view their behavior as motivated by greed in qui tam cases.


The role of whistleblowing in the fight against corruption and risk involved

Corruption is a notoriously secretive activity and it is usually only those engagedin corrupt deals or those who work with them that are aware of it. Insiders are among the few people who are able to report cases of corruption (past or ongoing) and identify the risk of future wrongdoing. By helping to detect corruption cases, whistleblowers play a critical role in converting a vicious cycle of secrecy into a virtuous cycle .Major bribery and corruption scandals demonstrate the damage done by the failure to report wrongdoing as soon as it is discovered. Yet indifference, fear of reprisal, and misplaced loyalty as well as an overall culture of silence often deter potential witnesses and whistleblowers from speaking out.

“Whistleblowing” or “public interest disclosure” entails disclosure made in good faith that the information revealed is true, serves the interest of the public at large, and increases accountability within Government (and/or the private sector, depending on the legislation). Most countries vary on the types and scope of subject matter that are covered, with some countries clearly defining the scope and others, such as India, leaving it more vague. Coverage for protection also ranges from only Central Government employees, to both State and Central Government employees, to Government contractors and the private sector.

Whistleblowing is increasingly recognised as an important tool in the prevention and detection of corruption and other malpractice.By disclosing wrongdoing in an organisation, whistleblowers can avert harm, protect human rights, help to save lives and safeguard the rule of law. The clandestine nature of corrupt behaviour means that it may never come to light unless cases are reported by people who discover them in the course of their work. But reporting can come at a high price: whistleblowers often expose themselves to great personal risks in order to protect the public interest. As a result of speaking out, they may lose their jobs, dampen their career prospects, and even put their own lives at risk. 

Persecution of whistleblowers has become a serious issue in many parts of the world:

Employees in academia, business or government might become aware of serious risks to health and the environment, but internal policies might pose threats of retaliation to those who report these early warnings. Private company employees in particular might be at risk of being fired, demoted, denied raises and so on for bringing environmental risks to the attention of appropriate authorities. Government employees could be at a similar risk for bringing threats to health or the environment to public attention, although perhaps this is less likely.


Whistleblower protection

Whistleblower protection refers to laws and policies meant to protect anyone who exposes alleged wrongdoing. The wrongdoing might take the form of fraud, corruption or mismanagement.

While countries such as the USA and the UK had enacted laws to ensure whistleblower protection in the late 1980s and late 1990s (respectively), the early 2000s saw a surge in such legislation around the world, such as in South Africa (2000) and Japan (2004). At the same time, the Right to Information and anti-corruption movements gathered speed around the world. The United Nations’ Convention against Corruption (UNCAC) was also set up in 2005 and part of the Group of 20 (G20)’s Anti-Corruption Action Plan drafted in Seoul in 2010 specifically focused on whistleblower protection.

There are still several countries, however, including India and Russia, which have yet to enact such legislation. In India, for example, while the proposed Public Interest Disclosure and Protection to Persons Making the Disclosure Bill, 2010 (PID Bill, 2010), was passed by the Lok Sabha (Lower House) in 2010, it has not yet been ratified by the Rajya Sabha (Upper House) of Parliament. 

Need/relevance of appropriate whistleblowing legislation of legislation

There have been multiple instances of threatening, harassment and even murder of various whistleblowers.

RTI activists are vulnerable human rights defenders (HRDs) in India. Unlike other HRDs, a majority of the RTI activists are not part of an organisation; they often act alone, moved by anger at corruption and other illegal activities. RTI activists are vulnerable because they live in the same areas as public authorities and political leaders who do not want information about their activities to be disclosed. For the most part, human rights defenders receive media attention only when killed or seriously injured. When complaints are made by RTI activists, law enforcement personnel (who often work with corrupt officials) do not take appropriate action. The Right to Information Act, 2005 provides inadequate protection to whistleblowers. The Central Information Commission and the State Information Commissions are not mandated to deal with such threats or attacks or to provide protection when needed.

So the demands are that a law should be framed to protect whistleblowers.

Appropriate whistleblowing legislation and the means to enforce it are necessary to support a culture of compliance and integrity. Several international conventions recognize whistleblowing as an effective tool for fighting corruption,fraud and mismanagement, and commit the signatory countries to implement appropriate legislation.However, existing legal provisions are fragmented and weakly enforced in most jurisdictions.Only in rare cases do they provide sufficient protection for whistleblowers. Many laws may cover only the public sector or may be not tailored to the specific needs of whistleblowers.Comprehensive legislation, as provided under the United Kingdom’s Public Interest Disclosure Act, is the exception rather than the rule.

There may be an over-reliance on general criminal laws that oblige individuals to report criminal offences to a country’s law enforcement authorities.In such circumstances, the assumption is that individuals would automatically be exempted from any form of retaliation if a crime was involved. Practice has shown, however, that the existence of a legal duty to report is seldom a satisfactory alternative to a proper whistleblowing policy and protective measures. The same problem applies to the reliance on witness protection mechanisms. Not all whistleblowers are witnesses. They often do not have any concrete evidence, but only suspect wrongdoing. As a result, witness protection mechanisms do not provide sufficient protection to whistleblowers, nor do they pursue the same goal.At the same time, the overall legislative framework needs to provide sufficient protections and compensation for those wrongly accused, even by whistleblowers who report in good faith. The assumption of innocence needs to be respected until responsibility is sufficiently proven.

The Public Interest Disclosure and Protection to Persons Making the Disclosures Bill, 2010


Analysis :

According to Indian law reports, the bill has faced considerable criticism because its jurisdiction is restricted to the government sector and encompasses only those who are working for the Government of India or its agencies; it does not cover the state-government employees. However, the draft bill aimed at protecting whistleblowers is seen as a welcome move.

The proposed law has neither provisions to encourage whistleblowing (financial incentives), nor deals with corporate whistleblowers; it does not extend its jurisdiction to the private sector (a strange omission, after the fraud at Satyam). The Directorate of Income Tax Intelligence and Criminal Investigation is one of the only agencies empowered for whistle blower protection.

The bill aims to balance the need to protect honest officials from harassment with protecting persons making a public-interest disclosure. It outlines sanctions for false complaints. However, it does not provide a penalty for attacking a complainant.

The Central Vigilance Commission (CVC) was designated in 2004 to receive public-interest disclosures through government resolution; there have been a few hundred complaints every year. The provisions of the bill are similar to that of the resolution. Therefore, it is unlikely that the number of complaints will differ significantly.The power of the CVC is limited to making recommendations. It cannot impose penalties, in contrast to the powers of the Karnataka and Delhi Lokayuktas.

The bill has a limited definition of disclosure, and does not define victimisation. Other countries (such as the United States, United Kingdom and Canada) define disclosure more widely and define victimisation.

It differs on many issues with the proposed Bill of the Law Commission and the Second Administrative Reform Commission’s report. These include non-admission of anonymous complaints and lack of penalties for officials who victimise whistleblowers.

If enacted, the law to protect whistleblowers will assist in detecting corruption, ensuring better information flow and paving the way for successful prosecution of corrupt individuals through clear and protected processes. However, the public in India have a low level of confidence in fighting corruption because they fear retaliation and intimidation against those who file complaints. Another worry pertains to the delay in disposing of these cases. Without public debate on the provisions of this proposed law, it is clear that people cannot measure its effectiveness when the draft bill comes into force as law.




TI recommendations
A single, comprehensive legal framework is most effective


To ensure a safe alternative to silence for whistleblowers, the legal framework should be clear, comprehensive and easy to use for protecting the whistleblower.Ideally, a single legislative framework should be in place, but provisions in different bills can fulfil the same purpose if they do not leave loopholes or become too complicated. In all cases,the legislation should cover the public,private and not-for-profit sectors and provide for reliable reporting channels to communicate concerns. Legislation should include a broad range of issues, from criminal offences to the potential harm that wrongdoing can cause, such as to the health and safety of citizens and the environment. Whistleblowing legislation should provide that organisations in the public and private sector establish,maintain, and routinely publicise appropriate mechanisms for internal reporting.

Safety should be ensured for whistleblowers


Both public and private employees and those outside the traditional employee-employer relationship (e.g. consultants,temporary workers, trainees, etc.) should be protected from reprisal for honestly reporting concerns. Protection should also be extended to those attempting to report or corroborating reports and include a right to refuse participation in wrongdoings. Any individuals closely associated with the whistleblower, such as family members, should be covered as well. In case of retaliation against the whistleblower, the burden of proof to show that this discrimination is not related should lie with the employer. These protections should be guaranteed by access to normal court procedures.Whistleblowers should be protected against any damages suffered as a consequence of their disclosure. They should receive some kind of professional or social recognition for having prevented excessive harm to the organisation or society. Such a system, potentially in cluding financial rewards, should be carefully designed, taking the particular national and legal contexts into account.

Internal and external reporting should be protected

Where possible, reports or concerns should first be raised internally and to the appropriate body set up by the organisation with assurances that whistleblower confidentiality is clearly established. This allows organisations time and space to investigate the nature and substance of a report without unfairly exposing the subject of a report or the organisation to unfounded allegations.In many instances, however, initially reporting internally might not be a possibility.Whistleblowers may fear retaliation for filing an internal report, the report may not be followed up internally for various reasons (e.g. where malpractices are institutionalised or where managers are concerned about the negative impact on the image of the institution or on themselves), or the public interest may be best served by immediately filing the report externally to the authorities or other agencies. Whistleblowers should have a safe option to report externally to the regulator, enforcement authorities or to other competent oversight bodies. This is particularly important in cases where there is an immediate risk to the health and safety of people. As a last resort, disclosures to the media should also be protected.The British Public Interest Disclosure Act (PIDA), for instance, takes different factors and consequences of whistleblowing for people and organisations into account. It is an example of a model that allows for internal and external reporting, establishing three levels of disclosure.

Enforcement is essential

While the existence of a legal framework is a pre-condition for whistleblower protection, it is not sufficient. Legislation needs to be effectively enforced and should be as sound and consistent as possible. To ensure the proper implementation of legal provisions, an independent public body with sufficient autonomy should be set up or designated to oversee the functioning of the law and to receive and investigate complaints. Enforcement should include consultations with key stakeholders like trade unions, business associations and civil society actors so that whistleblowing policies can be agreed upon and put into effect.

The need for effective follow-up mechanisms in organisations


To realise the potential of whistleblowing legislation, the legal framework should be complemented with effective follow-up mechanisms in organisations. There also must be a willingness in organisations (whether a public in stitution, private company or not-for-profit) to provide sufficient resources, to investigate cases through independent bodies, to implement necessary changes and to hold those responsible for wrongdoing to account.In recognition of the potential of whistleblowing for effective risk management in organisations, a number of related provisions and guidelines have been developed. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act, a law in the US which sets financial reporting standards for public companies, mandates whistleblower protection mechanisms for public companies registered in the country.The International Chamber of Commerce also has adopted voluntary guidelines and the British Standards Institute has developed a code which establishes best practice for whistleblowing in organisations.But recent cases show that existing laws and practices are not enough and that much more needs to be done to realise the potential benefits of whistleblowing.For example, the multi-billion dollar fraud scheme of Bernard L. Madoff, a US- based hedge fund manager, was first detected in 1992, but no action was taken.An official investigation into the case found that six substantive complaints were filed by whistleblowers to the appropriate bodies but the government never followed up on them. Madoff’s scheme eventually cost thousands of investors billions of dollars.

Recommendations:

Strong and transparent internal policies are needed in organisations

Trustworthy and effective policies and procedures are essential to create the right environment for honest reporting in organisations. As part of well-designed ethics and anti-corruption codes, organisations should implement a clear and distinct whistleblowing policy. Whistleblowing procedures should provide for a variety of easy and accessible channels that can be used to disclose information,such as to the line manager, an ethics committee, the ombudsperson, internal hotlines or web-based reporting tools.Policies and procedures should also clearly separate personal grievances from whistleblower reports, offer guidance and procedures for internal and external reporting, provide sufficient feedback to the whistleblowers, establish appropriate follow-up mechanisms with timeframes,and protect people from retaliation. It is essential that whistleblower procedures are supported by the top management and accepted and well-known by the members of the organisations.

Confidential reporting must be ensured

Reporting channels in an organisation should offer people the opportunity to report concerns confidentially or even anonymously. Confidentiality is needed to establish trust with the whistleblower who faces numerous risks when reporting,while also allowing the organisation to establish the facts of a case. The whistleblower’s identity should be protected and only be disclosed if she or he agrees to this or if it is required by law.Confidentiality also helps to protect thefundamental rights of the person suspected of wrongdoing.

Impartial and accountable investigations need to be carried out

After a disclosure is received, the organisation should focus on the nature and substance of a report, and not on the person making it. Reports should be fully and fairly investigated; while the organisation should also take suitable correctiveaction when a report is well-founded. A record should be kept on how a reportwas managed so the organisation can learn from the experience.

Good communication and consultation with staff is needed

Whistleblowing policies must be fully supported by the leadership of the organisation and should be adequately promoted and clearly communicated throughout the organisation. When designing and implementing the policy,employees, directors and other stakeholders should be properly consulted,briefed and trained. The achievements of whistleblowing mechanisms shouldbe regularly communicated to the members of the organisations and to the public, and staff should be consulted regularly in order to identify areas for improvement.

The demand for a shift in culture

The importance of whistleblowing in the detection and prevention of wrongdoing is still generally under-valued. It is an inexpensive risk management tool with particular benefits for emerging democracies with less established oversight mechanisms. Whistleblowing is also a tool to sound the alarm at early stages, potentially even before any damage has been caused.Nevertheless, whistleblowers are often perceived as disloyal, rather than as champions of the public interest. In many countries they are viewed as untrustworthy, and sometimes even as spies or traitors.

Recommendations

Public support is needed to promote whistleblowing To change this perception, whistleblowing needs to be promoted as an effective tool for stopping corrupt ion and serving the public interest.Governments should lend their support to public information campaigns as well as initiatives to promote whistleblowing that are carried out by professional groups, Ombudspersons,industry, media, trade unions and other civil society organisations. Whistleblowers should not only be protected by public authorities, but also honoured and actively supported.

Data on the public benefit of whistleblowing should be collected and published

Data from the United States show the relevance of whistleblowing for the recovery of public revenues (see side bar on page 6). Yet on a global scale there is little data available on the number of cases reported, the effectiveness of reporting channels and the financial benefits due to whistleblowing. This lack of data could be addressed by making more court and tribunal decisions public and by standardising whistleblowing procedures across the public sector. Given the central role of whistleblowing in detecting and preventing wrongdoing, gathering reliable statistics will greatly help decision-makers and the public to measure progress in uncovering corruption.

A proper societal and legal environment is needed

A legislative environment, ensuring freedom of expression, access to information and the existence of an independent media are critical to enable a culture of whistleblowing. Protection of journalists’ sources should include information provided by whistleblowers, even if journalists might base their reports at times on erroneous information given in good faith. The growing relevance of internet tools provides whistleblowers with new channels for reporting and thereby creates a global platform which increasingly can help ensure that whistleblowing becomes and remains an important issue in the public debate.

TI’s Recommendations for Whistleblowing: At a Glance


A single, comprehensive legal framework is most effective.
Safety should be ensured for whistleblowers.
Internal and external reporting should beprotected.
Enforcement is essential.
Strong and transparent internal policies are neededin organisations.
Confidential reporting mustbe ensured.
Impartial and accountable investigations need to becarried out.
Good communication andconsultation with staff isneeded.
Public support is needed topromote whistleblowing.
Data on the public benefit of whistleblowing should becollected and published.
A proper societal and legal environment is needed.

Saturday, February 9, 2013

Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA)


Introduction

The Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA)-1958 was enacted by the Parliament on September 11, 1958, to provide necessary powers and legal protection to the Armed Forces while carrying out proactive operations against the insurgents in a highly hostile environment. Since then, the Armed Forces have been able to effectively contain insurgency and establish stability in the region. It grants special powers to the armed forces in what the act calls "disturbed areas". AFSPA was first applied to the Northeastern States of Assam and Manipur, and was amended in 1972 to extend to the other States of Tripura, Meghalaya, Arunachal Pradesh, Mizoram and Nagaland.It was later extended to Jammu and Kashmir as The Armed Forces (Jammu and Kashmir) Special Powers Act, 1990 in July 1990.

Operational Importance of AFSPA

 An analysis of ground realities vis-a-vis the situation in early 1950s makes it evident that the fighting capability of the militants in the North East and J&K has improved considerably over the years. They possess sophisticated weapons, modern communication equipment and have moral and financial support from across the borders. Areas close to the international border witness trans-border movement of militants from their camps and hide-outs in neighbouring countries.

The Armed Forces are required to operate in varied terrain such as thick forests, in far flung areas and also in the built up areas ranging from small hutments and villages to towns and cities, where the insurgents have established their training camps and support bases. Not only do the troops operate in hostile terrain, they also work in an unfriendly population environment exposing themselves to grave dangers demanding very high degree of operational effectiveness. At the same time, the Armed Forces are under pressure to be extremely cautious and avoid collateral damage and loss of innocent lives or property. Any violation or perceived violation attracts media attention and provides a opportunity for propaganda to factions with vested interests. On most occasions, allegations have been found to be false and evidence fabricated but nevertheless, have to be answered, rebutted or contended with. Operating under such environment requires a protective law lest the forces get embroiled in legal battles and their effectiveness is reduced in operations for which they have been deployed in the first place. 

Militants in different parts of the country exploit popular anger and frustration of the people at the failures of the civil administration on the development and welfare fronts. It has to be stopped. In order to get to the root of the problem one needs to take a look at the wider scenario where underground outfits have created violent security situations to further their causes and AFSPA had to be enforced.

It is the duty of the State to harmonize the rights of the individual on one hand and with the requirement of the community on the other. The Central Government vide Art 355 of the Constitution of India is duty bound to protect every State not only against the external aggression but also internal disturbances and to ensure that the governance of every State is carried out in accordance with the provisions of the Constitution of India. 

Provisions under AFSPA

Powers to declare areas to be disturbed areas (Section 3 of the Act)

In relation to any state or Union Territory to which this act extends, the Governor of that State or the administrator of that Union Territory or the Central Government, in either case, if of the opinion that the whole or any part of such State of Union territory, as the case may be, is in such a disturbed or dangerous condition that the use of armed forces in aid of the civil power is necessary, the Governor of that State or the Administrator of that Union Territory or the Central Government, as the case may be , may by notification in the Official Gazette,declare the whole or such part of such State or Union territory to be a disturbed area

The Governor is empowered to declare any area of the State as “disturbed area’. It could not be arbitrary on ground of absence of legislative guidelines (Inderjit Barua v.State of Assam)

Section 3 cannot be construed as conferring a power to issue a declaration without any time limit. There should be periodic review of the declaration before the expiry of six months; Naga People’s Movement of Human Rights v. Union of India.

Special Powers of the armed forces (Under the AFSPA)

 Any commissioned officer, warrant officer, non-commissioned officer or any other person of equivalent rank in the armed forces may, in a disturbed area can
  • Fire upon or use other kinds of force even if it causes death, against the person who is acting against law or order in the disturbed area for the maintenance of public order, after giving such due warning.
  • Destroy any arms dump, prepared or fortified position or shelter or training camp from which armed attacks are made by the armed volunteers or armed gangs or absconders wanted for any offence
  • To arrest without a warrant anyone who has committed cognizable offenses or is reasonably suspected of having done so and may use force if needed for the arrest.
  • To enter and search any premise in order to make such arrests, or to recover any person wrongfully restrained or any arms, ammunition or explosive substances and seize it.
  • Stop and search any vehicle or vessel reasonably suspected to be carrying such person or weapons.
  • Any person arrested and taken into custody under this Act shall be made over to the officer in charge of the nearest police station with the least possible delay, together with a report of the circumstances occasioning the arrest.
  • Army officers have legal immunity for their actions. There can be no prosecution, suit or any other legal proceeding against anyone acting under that law. Nor is the government's judgment on why an area is found to be disturbed subject to judicial review.
  • Protection of persons acting in good faith under this Act from prosecution, suit or other legal proceedings, except with the sanction of the Central Government, in exercise of the powers conferred by this Act.
  
Demand to Repeal/Revoke AFSPA

According to those who want repeal of AFSPA,the large scale violations of  fundamental rights in the north eastern states and kashmir is a direct consequence of the provisions of the AFSPA.The AFSPA, which grants armed forces personnel the power to shoot to arrest, search, seize and even shoot to kill, violates the Right to Life enshrined in Article 21 of the Constitution of India which guarantees the right to life to all people.The AFSPA also violates the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR). India signed the ICCPR in 1978, taking on the responsibility of securing the rights guaranteed by the Covenant to all its citizens. In particular, the Act is in contravention of Article 6 of the ICCPR guaranteeing the right to life.Some believe that AFSPA seeks to supplant rather than supplement civil authority with military authority in the administration of everyday life.It  blurs the necessary distinctions between the police and the military, between the civilian and the combatant, and between ‘domestic’ and ‘alien’ space.

Jeevan Reddy Commission on AFSPA stated that "the Act, for whatever reason, has become a symbol of oppression, an object of hate and an instrument of discrimination and high handedness." The report also stated that "It is highly desirable and advisable to repeal the Act altogether, without of course, losing sight of the overwhelming desire of an overwhelming majority of the (North East) region that the Army should remain (though the Act should go)".The report recommends the incorporation of AFSPA in the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967, which will be operable all over India.


Provisions against misuse of the Act

It is also an established fact that the judiciary is the custodian of the Constitution. An independent judicial system performs better than any other agency to maintain prefect equilibrium between the liberty of the. individual and the powers of the State. It is in this light, it is emphasized that the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India has upheld the constitutional validity of the Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act. The court further observed that the instructions issued by the military authorities in the form of 'DO's' and DON'Ts while acting under the AFSPA are to be treated as binding instructions which are required to be followed by the members of, the Armed Forces. 

Adequate checks and safeguards are built in the AFSPA to prevent the Armed Forces from assuming sweeping powers. Violations of its provisions are liable for legal action and prosecution. The DO's and DON'Ts issued to the units having found approval of Apex Court have acquired legal status, are binding on the troops which are restraining factors to ensure the guidelines are taken very seriously and promt disciplinary action is taken against the defaulters under Army Act 1950.

It is reiterated that the Armed Forces of the Union deployed in aid of the Civil Powers have to operate in the State concerned in co-operation with the Civil Administration to deal with the situation affecting maintenance of public order which has necessitated the deployment or Armed Forces so that normalcy is restored. Thus the governance of the State yet remains in the hands of Civil Administration and not taken over by the Armed Forces, as is wrongly perceived by many people.The armed forces must act in cooperation with the district administration and not as an Independent body. Armed Forces could work in harmony when they deployed in disturbed area.

From bare reading of the Act, it appears that security forces enjoy vast powers, which are akin to the powers vested in the local police, yet power to investigate the offences remains reserved with the police alone.
Arrested persons to be made over to the police –Any person arrested and taken into custody under this Act shall be made over to the officer in charge of the nearest police station with the least possible delay, together with a report of the circumstances occasioning the arrest.

By analysing the issue of safeguard further, it would transpire that the protection envisaged is for only those persons, who act in good faith in discharge of their official duties and not otherwise. Acting in good faith would mean to act without any malice in the discharge of the official duties, i.e., exercising due care and caution. Sec 7 of the Act reads thus :-­

"Protection of persons acting in good faith under this Act. No prosecution, suit or other legal proceeding shall be instituted except with the previous sanction of the Central Government against any person in respect of anything done or purported to be done in exercise of the powers conferred by this Act."

The protection under Section 7 would not be available to a member of the security forces, who commits acts which constitute criminal offences not in the discharge of his official duties even in the area which has been declared as disturbed. 

Supreme Court Judgements

Conferment of power on non-commissioned officers like a Havaldar cannot be said to be bad and unjustified ( Inderjit Barua v .State of Assam )

The Governor is empowered to declare any area of the State as “disturbed area’. It could not be arbitrary on ground of absence of legislative guidelines (Inderjit Barua v.State of Assam)

Section 3 cannot be construed as conferring a power to issue a declaration without any time limit. There should be periodic review of the declaration before the expiry of six months; Naga People’s Movement of Human Rights v. Union of India.

In the stringent operating environment it is but human to make mistakes. While mistakes do occur the guilty must be justly punished. Army has been unilaterally taking disciplinary actions against defaulters under the Provision of the Army Act.

Soldier functioning in areas where AFSPA is in place is not above the law of the country. If and when the government feels that a crime has been committed which requires punishment in accordance with the law of the land it retains the right to give sanction for prosecution and put the process of civil law into motion; this by itself places a huge check on the conduct of the forces personnel. Also, trial by a military court is not easy on an offender; military courts are known to mete out swift and more severe punishment than that given by the civilian courts.

The nation has to be assured that personnel from the army, the Para-military forces, the Police services or any other government agency are subject to stringent disciplinary procedures which greatly reduce the possibility of their indulging in such heinous crimes and that the miniscule few who do so are brought to book much faster than their civilian counterparts. The army in particular needs to inform the public about the actions that it has taken and is taking to ensure that its soldiers are properly educated, indoctrinated and monitored to ensure that they do not indulge in barbaric acts. Also the process by which such heinous crimes, if committed, would be handled in places which are under AFSPA should be made public.

The common ground between the supporters and detractors of AFSPA is that, AFSPA can only be a temporary phase to bring normalcy to a disturbed area, restore democratic institutions and create an atmosphere where these institutions can function normally. The main disagreement is on the timing of it’s removal. Increasingly, the public, rightfully, is emerging as an important stakeholder whose opinion has started to matter a lot in issues such as AFSPA.

Details of the Act -- Click Here

Thursday, September 6, 2012

Foreign Contribution Regulation Act (FCRA)






What is Foreign Contribution Regulation Act ?

The FCRA aims to regulate the acceptance and utilisation of foreign contribution and foreign hospitality by persons and associations .The focus of the Act is to ensure that the foreign contribution and foreign hospitality is not utilized to affect or influence electoral politics, public servants, judges and other people working the important areas of national life like journalists, printers and publishers of newspapers, etc. The Act also seeks to regulate flow of foreign funds to voluntary organizations with the objective of preventing any possible diversion of such funds towards activities detrimental to the national interest and to ensure that individuals and organizations may function in a manner consistent with the values of the sovereign democratic republic.

What is a foreign source according to the Act ?

(1) the Government of any foreign country or territory and any agency of such Government
(2) any international agency, not being the United Nations or any of its specialized agencies, the World Bank, International Monetary Fund
(3) a foreign company
(4) a corporation, not being a foreign company, incorporated in a foreign country or territory
(5) a multi-national corporation
(6) a foreign trust or a foreign foundation
(7) a citizen of a foreign country
(8) a trade union in any foreign country or territory

What is not considered as foreign contribution ?

Contributions made by a citizen of India living in another country (i.e., Non-Resident Indian who still hold Indian citizenship), from his personal savings, through the normal banking channels, is not treated as foreign contribution.Donation from an Indian who has acquired foreign citizenship is treated as foreign contribution. This will also apply to PIO card holders and to Overseas Citizens of India.

Who can receive foreign contribution?

A person/ngo/trust/association having a definite cultural, economic, educational, religious or social programme can receive foreign contribution after it obtains the prior permission of the Central Government, or gets itself registered with the Central Government.

Who cannot receive foreign contribution?

Foreign contribution cannot be accepted by :
(a) a candidate for election
(b) correspondent, columnist, cartoonist, editor, owner, printer or publisher of a registered newspaper
(c) Judge, government servant or employee of any Corporation or any other body controlled on owned by the Government
(d) member of any legislature
(e) political party
(f) organization of a political nature
(g) association or company engaged in the production or broadcast of audio news or audio visual news or current affairs programmes through any electronic mode
(h) correspondent or columnist, cartoonist, editor, owner of a media company.

What are the conditions to be met for the grant of registration and prior permission to receive foreign funds under FCRA ?

(a) The 'person' making an application for registration or grant of prior permission- (i) is not fictitious or benami; (ii) has not been prosecuted or convicted for indulging in activities aimed at conversion through inducement or force, either directly or indirectly, from one religious faith to another; (iii) has not been prosecuted or convicted for creating communal tension or disharmony in any specified district or any other part of the country; (iv) has not been found guilty of diversion or mis-utilisation of its funds; (v) is not engaged or likely to engage in propagation of sedition or advocate violent methods to achieve its ends; (vi) is not likely to use the foreign contribution for personal gains or divert it for undesirable purposes;(vii) has not contravened any of the provisions of this Act; (viii) has not been prohibited from accepting foreign contribution; (ix) the person being an individual, such individual has neither been convicted under any law for the time being in force nor any prosecution for any offence is pending against him.

(b).the acceptance of foreign contribution by the association/ person is not likely to affect prejudicially – (i) the sovereignty and integrity of India; or (ii) the security, strategic, scientific or economic interest of the State; or (iii) the public interest; or (iv) freedom or fairness of election to any Legislature; or (v) friendly relation with any foreign State; or (vi) harmony between religious, racial, social, linguistic, regional groups, castes or communities. (c) the acceptance of foreign contribution- (i) shall not lead to incitement of an offence; (ii) shall not endanger the life or physical safety of any person.

Can the NGOs invest the money received from foreign source ?

NGOs cannot use the foreign contributions for investment in Mutual Funds and other speculative investments,they cannot invest the foreign contribution received  in any  profitable ventures.

Is there any restriction on transfer of funds to other organisations?

The funds cannot be transferred from one organisation to other organisations unless such other person/org is also registered and had been granted the certificate or obtained the prior permission under this Act.

A person who has been granted a certificate of registration or prior permission under  and intends to transfer part of the foreign contribution received by him to a person who has not been granted a certificate of registration or prior permission under the Act, may transfer such foreign contribution to an extent not exceeding ten per cent of the total value thereof and for this purpose, make an application to the Central Government.

Can the Government suspend the certificate of registration granted to a person under FCRA?

Yes

Why is FCRA in news ?

Government cancelled the registration of many NGOs over violations in the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act (FCRA).Use of foreign funds in the agitations and accounting irregularities led to action against NGOs under FCRA.




Monday, May 28, 2012

Biotechnology Regulatory Authority of India Bill





The government is gearing up to regulate the research and use of organisms and products of modern bio-technology. It has prepared a draft Bill to establish Biotechnology Regulatory Authority of India ( BRAI), which will be an autonomous and statutory agency to regulate the research, transport, import, manufacture and use of organisms and products of modern bio-technology.

 The authority would consist of a chairperson, two whole-time members and two part-time members, each with expertise in life sciences and biotechnology applications in agriculture, health care, environment and general biology.

The Bill provides for setting up of inter-ministerial governing board to oversee the performance of the authority and a National Biotechnology Advisory Council of stakeholders to provide feedback on use of organisms and products of biotechnology in society.

The Bill also provides for an elaborate risk assessment process involving scientific panels of experts and representatives of concerned ministries including a special public review system for evaluation of applications before final approvals.

Criticisms - CLICK